Hi

The ForEach loop has changed in behaviour in 9.2.5, or maybe in 9.2.0. First of all the 'use column' works differently. I had a job where we had use column = 2 in previous version, and when we upgraded we had to change to use column = 1 to get the same result. Have you changed the start index of columns from 1 to 0 ?



Secondly the x values are not preserved during the loop. I have created a job you can run. I would expect to get the same result in task 2 and 3, but they are different.



  LoopTest.zip (3kb) downloaded 26 time(s).

Hi

The ForEach loop has changed in behaviour in 9.2.5, or maybe in 9.2.0. First of all the 'use column' works differently. I had a job where we had use column = 2 in previous version, and when we upgraded we had to change to use column = 1 to get the same result. Have you changed the start index of columns from 1 to 0 ?



Secondly the x values are not preserved during the loop. I have created a job you can run. I would expect to get the same result in task 2 and 3, but they are different.



  LoopTest.zip (3kb) downloaded 26 time(s).

Hi Thomas,

I just wanted to let you know that we're investigating this. We will get back to you when we know more

---

Hi

The ForEach loop has changed in behaviour in 9.2.5, or maybe in 9.2.0. First of all the 'use column' works differently. I had a job where we had use column = 2 in previous version, and when we upgraded we had to change to use column = 1 to get the same result. Have you changed the start index of columns from 1 to 0 ?



Secondly the x values are not preserved during the loop. I have created a job you can run. I would expect to get the same result in task 2 and 3, but they are different.



  LoopTest.zip (3kb) downloaded 26 time(s).

Update: We've fixed this issue in our 9.2.5 build (which we plan on releasing very soon). You can download it here: https://www.visualcron.c....aspx?g=Posts&t=9975 

---

Hi

Thx for the fix, it seems to work now.

By the way, I noticed that if I choose an columns that is outside the index bounds, it doesn't fail.
Lets's say we are looping over a list of strings. If I select use column 0, it works. If I select column 1, it returns a message as an output, but doesn't fail the task. See image:



Wouldn't it make more sense to throw an error?

Hi

Thx for the fix, it seems to work now.

By the way, I noticed that if I choose an columns that is outside the index bounds, it doesn't fail.
Lets's say we are looping over a list of strings. If I select use column 0, it works. If I select column 1, it returns a message as an output, but doesn't fail the task. See image:



Wouldn't it make more sense to throw an error?

Thanks for reporting this. We will look in to it as well. Is it hindering any of your tasks currently? Or is it just a heads up in advance

---

Hi

Thanks. No this is not a problem for us currently